A route line that crosses over itself is usually a longer route than it had to be, and you can see that on a map before you do any math. You can find the rest of the waste the same way, by mapping a week of routes you’ve already run.
Once you put a price on the extra miles, you end up with a dollar range you can defend, and a list of the routes, stops and branch assignments the money came from.
What to put on the map
- Export one week of stops, one row for each stop, with its address.
- Add columns for driver, branch, date and the order the stop was visited.
- Upload the sheet to a map.
- Color the pins by driver, then by branch.
- Show the visit number on each pin.
Use the order the stops were visited in wherever you have it, from job timestamps or driver logs. The planned order is second best. In Maptive, the Grouping Tool colors the pins, the Filter Tool narrows the map to one day or one driver, and “Labels Inside Markers” in Map Settings puts the visit number on each pin.
Six routing waste patterns and how each looks on a map
Most of the patterns below come with a quick check. Putting the week on a map makes this kind of waste visible, but a pattern is only a reason to ask why. Some of them turn out to have good reasons.
Crossing route lines
One driver’s line for the day crosses over itself. Or the stop numbers jump around, with stop 4 next to stop 11.
Crossing is a good sign of waste because, in a single route, two legs that cross can usually be uncrossed into a shorter route. Real roads have exceptions. A one-way street or a river can force a crossing, and so can a promised appointment window, such as a job booked for 1:00 to 3:00. So a crossing tells you where to check and proves nothing by itself. Work out which crossings happened because of an appointment window and which ones nobody chose.
Backtracking
The route passes a later stop on its way to an earlier one, or it goes back to a neighborhood it already left. On the map you see out-and-back spurs, and visit numbers out of order along one road. It usually happens when stops are run in the order they were booked.
Stops served from the wrong branch
A pin colored for one branch is closer to another branch.
To check, put a circle around each branch, big enough that the circles cover every stop. You can use a drive time area if you’d rather measure by road. Drive time areas in Maptive assume ideal driving conditions.
Then get the numbers. Maptive’s radius export can return each stop once, for the circle it’s nearest to, with the driving time and distance from that center. Compare that nearest-branch column with the assigned-branch column in your own sheet. The rows where the two differ are the wrong-branch stops, and you use the driving distance column to price each one.
Two drivers covering the same streets
Color the pins by driver and filter to one day. If two colors are mixed through the same neighborhood, two vehicles drove there to do work that one could have done.
For a count, click a branch’s circle or drive time area and use Customize Metrics with a Group Count on the driver column. It shows how the stops inside that area split by driver. Some overlap is on purpose, such as a job that needs a certain skill or a customer who asks for one technician.
Long first and last legs
The leg from the yard to stop 1, or from the last stop back, is the longest of the day. That usually means the stop belongs to a nearer branch, or the driver starts from the yard when home is closer to the work.
A far stop can also be a choice. In areas without many customers, companies cover a wide area and charge the far customers more. Flag those stops so someone can decide to keep, reprice or drop them, and leave them out of the error count.
Unbalanced days
One day might have 19 stops spread across the county while another has 8 in a single ZIP code. Or one driver has twice as many stops as another. Group the pins by day or by driver and read the count for each group.
How to turn extra miles into dollars
You need two numbers for the math. One is what a single mile costs, and the other is how many miles didn’t need to be driven. Start with the cost. It works better to have a floor and a ceiling than one number.
A cost per mile you can cite
The ceiling is the IRS standard mileage rate for business use, which has been 76 cents a mile since July 1, 2026. It was 72.5 cents for the first half of the year. The rate is a tax figure that covers both fixed costs and running costs, and it’s the number most owners recognize.
The floor is the part of the cost that goes up with every mile you drive. AAA’s 2026 figures put fuel at 17.3 cents a mile and maintenance, repair and tires at 11.7 cents, which is about 29 cents together. AAA’s numbers are for new personal vehicles, so treat that as a floor for a service van.
You need both numbers because insurance, loan payments and the depreciation that comes with age don’t drop when a route gets 8 miles shorter. Neither number includes the driver’s pay.
The extra-miles formula with a worked example
Take the miles on a route as it was run and subtract the miles the same stops would take in the best order. Multiply by the cost per mile, then by the number of days a year that route runs. Add up the routes.
Here’s an example with made-up numbers. Five extra miles a day across 20 vehicles over 250 working days is 25,000 miles. That’s $7,250 at 29 cents and $19,000 at 76 cents.
Then add the driver’s time. Its cost per mile depends on the speed you assume. At 30 mph, a mile takes two minutes. The Bureau of Labor Statistics put the median wage for heating, air conditioning and refrigeration mechanics and installers at $29.33 an hour in May 2025, which is about 98 cents for those two minutes before benefits. Add that to the 76 cents and a mile costs about $1.74.
Comparing a route as run with an optimized order
Take one driver’s Tuesday as an example, with 14 stops, out from the yard and back. Maptive’s Route Optimization and Directions tool takes up to 73 stops in a route, so 14 is well under the limit. When it optimizes, it keeps the first and last stops where they are. So set the yard as both the first stop and the last before you do anything else. Each route is for one driver.
Draw the route in the order it was run
Filter the map to that driver and that day so only those 14 stops show. In the routing panel, click “Lasso & Fill Locations” and draw around the pins to bring them all in. You can also add stops one at a time by clicking a marker, then its tools icon, and choosing “Add to Route”. Drag the stops into the order they were visited, with the yard first and last. Then click “Get Directions”.
Add the optimized order and compare the miles
Click “Optimize Route” and choose “Add another directions instance”. Maptive draws the optimized order as a second route on the same map, and you can name and color each one.
To get the miles, export each route. The export lists every stop with the approximate driving distance and travel time for each leg. Total the distance column for both routes.
Say the route as run comes to 58 miles and the optimized order comes to 49. The gap is 9 miles. If that route ran on 250 working days a year, that’s 2,250 miles, which is about $650 at 29 cents, $1,710 at 76 cents, and about $3,900 with the driver’s time at $1.74. Do the same for a sample of routes. You can keep several routes on one map, one for each driver.
What to change once you find the waste
Put the routes with the largest gaps into the better order, but first ask the driver why the old order was what it was. The reason may be a locked gate, a school zone or a customer who’s never home before ten. Move the wrong-branch stops to the nearer branch. In Maptive you can lasso a group of pins and change their branch column in one edit. Where two drivers share the same streets, draw each driver an area with the Territories Tool.
What a planning map cannot show
The order on the plan, or in the log, may not be what was driven. Researchers at the MIT Center for Transportation & Logistics reviewed a year of deliveries for a large soft drinks company and found that three out of four didn’t follow the planned sequence.
For the real miles, the idling and the detours, you need odometer logs, fuel cards or a telematics system. Maptive doesn’t track vehicles.
The optimized order has limits too. Maptive works out travel time from the speed limit on each road, so traffic isn’t counted. It doesn’t account for appointment windows, how long each job takes or what a vehicle can carry, and Maptive doesn’t schedule or dispatch. A route can have up to 73 stops, with the first and last fixed.
So the dollar figure is a range. Use it to decide which routes and branches to look at first.





